Don’t Say “West Papua” in Australia?

In September 2012, a 49 year old woman named Vikki Riley died when a car collided with her bicycle on a busy Darwin road. Vikki Riley was known for her fiery passion for refugees and her strong Catholic beliefs. She left behind her son, St Paul’s School student Elijah, 7, and her partner Jimmy Hatton, also aged 49.

Vikki was an Australian artist and activist who supported the people of East Timor and West Papua, and had just organised a successful art exhibition for refugees. She had previously worked as a journalist for ABC Victoria and the Kabul Press.

On 12 September 2012, Senator John Madigan (Democratic Labor Party, Victoria), moved a Condolence Motion in the Senate:

That the Senate—

(a) expresses its condolence at the death of Ms Vikki Riley who passed away on 10 September 2012 and extends this condolence particularly to her partner and son, as well as family, friends and those she campaigned tirelessly for;

(b) notes her advocacy on behalf of refugees and the people of West Papua and East Timor; and

(c) acknowledges her work with refugees and the people of West Papua and East Timor.

Senator Madigan’s condolence motion was co-sponsored by Senator Nick Xenophon (Independent, South Australia).

Senator MADIGAN said: Vikki Riley was a tireless campaigner for those in most need. She campaigned for refugees and oppressed people of other nations. Vikki was a woman of many talents. She worked as a journalist for the ABC Victoria and the Kabul Press.

She was an artist and used her love of painting to organise art workshops to help asylum seekers as they waited for their cases to be processed. Only last month, she organised a successful detainee art exhibition at the Northern Territory Supreme Court. She continued to assist refugees after they were released from detention, helping them to find accommodation and jobs.

Vikki was adopted by Aboriginal parents in Kallista, Victoria. Her adopted parents retained her surname after the adoption. Her partner, Jimmy Hatton, said this situation made her unique. She loved her partner and her son deeply, but she spent enormous time away from her loved ones to help those most in need.

Both the Australian Labor Party and the Liberal-National Coalition opposed this condolence motion because it had the words ‘West Papua’ in it.

Senator Nigel Scullion (Country Liberals, Northern Territory) walked over to Senator Madigan and said that the Liberal-National Coalition would vote in favour of the condolence motion is the words ‘West Papua’ were removed.

Senator Trish Crossin (Labor, Northern Territory) said she extended her personal condolences but that the Australian Labor Party wouldn’t support the condolence motion with the words ‘West Papua’ in it: ‘… the government will not be supporting this motion because of her involvement with West Papua, in that it is in conflict with our foreign policy.’

Senator Richard di Natale (Greens, Victoria) made the following statement:

“I am absolutely staggered that we are going to vote down a condolence motion for a great Australian who has campaigned tirelessly on a number of issues as well as the rights of refugees, somebody who has contributed to the artistic community and who has worked on East Timorese issues—something that Australians should all be proud of. Yet, on the basis of her advocacy for the people of West Papua, who are currently being slaughtered, we are going to vote down a condolence motion. Where is the courage to stand up and say: ‘Well done. You deserve our respect.’ It is appalling. Have we become China, that we cannot celebrate a great Australian citizen who has worked so hard on so many issues and deserves the respect of this parliament? I am absolutely appalled.”

Senator John Madigan refused to remove the words ‘West Papua’ (after consulting with Vikki Riley’s partner, Jimmy Hatton).

He called a division.

When the vote on the condolence motion was held, Senator John Madigan, Senator Nick Xenophon and the Australian Greens voted in favour. The entire Senate opposed the condolence motion because it had the words ‘West Papua.’

Some Senators left the chamber rather than vote.

Only the following Senators votes Yes:

Madigan, JJ

Xenophon, N

Di Natale, R

Hanson-Young, SC

Ludlam, S

Milne, C

Rhiannon, L

Siewert, R (teller)

Waters, LJ

Whish-Wilson, PS

Wright, PL


  1. Annette Culley

    An appalling bunch of cowards is all I can say. They should be ashamed of themselves. Good on those who voted in favour.

  2. Tess

    That Wikileaks cable shows: US set up ’Detachment-88’, US giant Freeport and BP have massive mining/resource interests in West Papua, and we all know from August’s ABC report that Australia is tangled up in Detachment-88 with arms and training.

    In short: No, our US puppetted politicians have been told that they must not \’upset\’ things in West Papua. Kudos to Madigan, Xenophon and the Greens and SHAME on ALP/LNP/MSM stooges.

  3. Lea

    ‘Cowards’ was also my immediate thought. A political system without room for individual moral compass and conscience seems to me to be desperately weak and even futile.

  4. Justice Crew

    US mafia gang in Canberra killing West Papuans. Sad only. please someone else raise up to challenge this mafia gang killing people in the name of democracy, liberty, capitalist. all bullshit. China or Iran… Please harry up.

  5. Mike

    Short memory! As suspected in 1975 (although covered up at the time), Australia, through the Whitlam govt, sanctioned the invasion of Portuguese Timor (East Timor) with the eventual murder of up to 200,000 in the ensuing years. This was continued through the Fraser period with negotiations on gas/oil in the Timor Sea on the table. I can still remember the streams of C130 Transporters flying into Darwin when East Timor had to be ‘rescued’ from that policy shortfall. Similar story with West Papua?? Although the invasion of East Timor was seen as ‘reunifying’ an ethnically similar population (ie: all on the same island but with either Dutch or Portuguese colonisation), the invasion of West Papua could never be justified on the same grounds. This was purely a land-grab.
    Condolences to Mr. Hatton and family in your loss of such a passionate person.

  6. Veronica

    May Vikki rest in perfect peace.

    I for one am absolutely ashamed of being an Australian.

    The Australian Labor Party and the Liberal-National Coalition who opposed this condolence motion because it had the words ‘West Papua’ should hang their heads in black burning shame. They have no conscience.

    They are turning a blind eye to human rights atrocities and genocide being committed by the Indonesian military in West Papua just like they did to East Timor.

    Readers may be interested in the following rally. I am sure that Vikki would have promoted it.


    Whatever the debate and whichever direction it may lead the reality is innocent West Papuans are victims of the Anti-Terrorist training provided by Australia to the Indonesian Security Forces. It is very well for the Federal Government to say that this has never been the intention. But for the ordinary Papuans, Australia is training the Indonesian military to kill West Papuans.

    What do ordinary Australian say?

    Come and speak your mind at our rally in front of the Parliament.

    End Five Decades of bloodshed and misery in West Papua (West New Guinea)


    Come and join West Papuan Community Rally together with other Australians.
    Greens Senator Richard Di Natale is expected to address the rally.

    Tuesday 18 September 2012

    Time: 11.30 am – 1.30 pm

    Venue: The grassy field across the road from the main entrance to the Parliament.

    West Papua Merdeka

  7. Lynda

    Playing ‘politics’ with the hearts and lives of people Australian’s can admire and honor is surely the sign of a weak government.
    Yet another blight on the state of play in Australian politics. Along with others, I am truly appalled by such behavior. .

  8. Pingback: GPJA #442 (Part 2): International news & Analysis – 28/9/12 « GPJA's Blog
  9. oreck vacuum for hardwood and carpet

    Now that musicians see the inner workings of those woodwinds,
    they can also be interested to have a look at a history from
    the ocarina, a review of Karl Ahrens’ Mountain Ocarinas and a profile of his story as an ocarina maker. Hardwood flooring in Denver will give a lot of style to your home. Now that you have considered everything relating in your environment let’s
    shift a persons vision in order to the gps unit itself. This vacuum isn’t produced for carpets or rugs since it doesn’t have any brush to clean up the rugs or carpet
    thoroughly. So, I can vacuum and still hold a conversation with my better
    half without yelling.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s